Astronomy 2e · Black Holes and Curved Spacetime

Tests of General Relativity

9 min read
Astronomical values (43 arcseconds/century, 1.75 arcseconds, Gravity Probe B rates, binary-pulsar decay rate) are commonly taught reference values; verify against current sources before citing in high-stakes contexts.
Want it in plain words first? Jump to Eli explains — the same idea, no jargon.
On this page 9 sections
  1. In 30 seconds
  2. Why this matters
  3. The college version
  4. Eli explains
  5. Worked example
  6. Key takeaway
  7. Check yourself
  8. Study tools
  9. Sources & references

In 30 seconds

When Albert Einstein published the general theory of relativity (GR) in 1915, he was replacing Isaac Newton's picture of gravity with something stranger: mass curves the four-dimensional fabric of spacetime, and what we call gravity is simply the natural way objects move through that curved geometry. A theory this bold had to make testable predictions, and within a few years the predictions started landing. The classic tests of GR are three: the extra advance of Mercury's orbit, the bending of starlight passing near the Sun, and the of light climbing out of a strong gravity well. Every one has been confirmed.

A century later the list has grown. Precision timing of a binary pulsar shows its orbit shrinking exactly as GR says it should, gyroscopes in orbit have measured the way Earth drags spacetime around with it, and in 2015 the LIGO detectors directly recorded gravitational waves — ripples in spacetime predicted by Einstein in 1916. This topic is about evidence: how astronomers and physicists went from a beautiful idea about curved spacetime to a theory that now guides GPS navigation, explains black holes, and has passed every experiment thrown at it. GR is not "just a theory" in the everyday sense — it is one of the best-tested theories in the history of science, and this topic shows you the tests.

Why this matters

General relativity is the framework for nearly everything this chapter and the rest of astronomy builds on: black holes, gravitational lensing, the expansion of the universe, and the orbits of stars around the supermassive black hole at the center of our galaxy. Understanding how GR is tested teaches you how science actually works — a theory earns trust by surviving repeated, independent checks. GR is also practical: without its corrections, GPS would drift out of usable alignment within a day (see Time in General Relativity). On exams, the tests of GR are favorite questions because each one pairs a prediction with the evidence that confirmed it — Mercury's orbit, Eddington's eclipse, the binary pulsar, and gravitational waves.

The college version

Core Concepts

The three classic tests

Mercury's . In Newtonian gravity, a single planet around the Sun follows a perfect ellipse, but the other planets tug on Mercury, slowly rotating its orbit so the closest point to the Sun (the perihelion) creeps forward over time. By the late 1800s, astronomers had measured the total precession and found it was larger than Newtonian calculations predicted by about 43 arcseconds per century (a commonly taught reference value — about 1/80,000 of a full circle). GR explained the missing amount exactly: near the Sun, spacetime is curved enough that Mercury's path deviates slightly from a Newtonian ellipse. This was the first quantitative success of the theory, and it remains a textbook example of a prediction matching observation.

Deflection of starlight. Light follows the straightest possible path through curved spacetime — a . Near a massive body like the Sun, that path bends. Einstein's theory predicted starlight grazing the Sun's edge would be deflected by about 1.75 arcseconds (a commonly taught reference value), twice the deflection a Newtonian "light as particles" calculation gives. In 1919, an expedition led by Arthur Eddington photographed a total solar eclipse and measured the apparent shift of background stars near the Sun's disk; the result matched GR, and the news made Einstein world-famous. Modern radio observations of distant quasars passing behind the Sun confirm the deflection to far higher precision, and the same effect — now called gravitational lensing — is a routine tool for finding dark matter and distant galaxies.

Gravitational redshift. Light climbing out of a gravity well must spend energy to escape, and because its speed is fixed, the energy loss appears as a stretching of wavelength — a shift toward the red. In 1960 the Pound–Rebka experiment measured this effect in a 22-meter tower at Harvard using gamma rays, and today the effect is so well confirmed that it must be programmed into GPS satellite clocks. The same physics, pushed to the extreme, predicts that light emitted at the edge of a black hole never escapes at all.

Frame dragging and the geodetic effect

Einstein's equations say a rotating mass drags spacetime around with it — the Lense–Thirring effect, often called . NASA's Gravity Probe B mission (2004–2005) tested this by putting four ultra-precise gyroscopes in orbit around Earth. If GR is right, the gyroscope axes should precess in two ways: a large effect from orbiting through curved spacetime (the , about 6.6 arcseconds per year) and a tiny effect from Earth's rotation dragging spacetime (about 0.039 arcseconds per year — commonly cited reference values). The measured values matched the predictions. Satellite laser-ranging data (LAGEOS missions) provided independent support.

The binary pulsar: a gravity laboratory

In 1974, Russell Hulse and Joseph Taylor discovered PSR B1913+16, a pulsar (a rapidly spinning neutron star emitting clock-like radio pulses) locked in orbit with another neutron star. By timing the pulses, they found the orbit shrinks by roughly 76 microseconds per year (a commonly cited reference value) — exactly the energy loss predicted if the system is radiating gravitational waves. This was the first indirect confirmation that gravitational waves exist and that GR correctly predicts their strength, earning Hulse and Taylor the 1993 Nobel Prize in Physics.

Gravitational waves as the newest test

On September 14, 2015, the twin LIGO detectors recorded the first direct detection of gravitational waves (event GW150914) — the merger of two black holes about 1.3 billion light-years away. The observed signal matched GR's predicted waveform so closely that it simultaneously confirmed the waves and tested GR's strong-field predictions for the first time (see Gravitational Wave Astronomy). Since then, dozens of mergers have been recorded, and GR has passed every one.

Common Confusions

Do Not ConfuseWithDifference
The bending of lightLight being "pulled" by gravity like a ballGR says light follows curved spacetime (a geodesic); it has no mass to be pulled with, yet the path still bends
Gravitational redshiftDoppler redshift (motion)Gravitational redshift comes from climbing out of a gravity well; Doppler shift comes from relative motion. Both stretch light, but for different reasons
Mercury's precessionThe precession of Earth's axisMercury's orbit rotates because of GR and planetary tugs; Earth's axis wobbles for a different reason (torque from the Sun and Moon)
"Einstein was right, so Newton was wrong"Newtonian gravity being uselessNewton's laws are an excellent approximation in weak gravity; GR refines them where gravity is strong or very precise
The 1.75-arcsecond deflectionThe 0.87-arcsecond Newtonian valueGR predicts twice the Newtonian deflection; the 1919 measurement distinguished the two theories
One test "proving" GRGR being acceptedNo single experiment settles a theory; GR won acceptance through many independent confirmations over a century
Eli, the EliExplains learning guide

Eli explains

The same idea, in plain words

Explain it like I’m 10

Einstein said gravity bends the space around heavy things, like a heavy ball bending a stretched sheet. If his idea was right, we should see three things: Mercury's orbit wiggling a tiny bit extra, starlight bending as it passes the Sun, and light losing energy as it climbs away from Earth. Scientists checked all three — and Einstein was right every time. Later they even caught ripples in the sheet itself, exactly like he predicted.

Worked example

Imagine you are an astronomer in 1919, testing whether light bends. During a total solar eclipse the Moon blocks the Sun's blinding disk, so stars near the Sun become visible. Your team photographs the star field, then waits six months until the Sun has moved away and photographs the same stars at night. You overlay the two images: the stars photographed with the Sun nearby appear shifted outward from the Sun's position. The shift's size near the Sun's limb — about 1.75 arcseconds — matches GR, not the Newtonian prediction of half that. The eclipse is not just a spectacle; it is a natural experiment that lets you compare two rival theories of gravity in one measurement. The same logic runs through every test in this topic: predict a number, measure the sky, compare.

Key takeaways

  • The three classic tests: Mercury's perihelion precession, deflection of starlight, and gravitational redshift — all confirmed.
  • Mercury's orbit advances ~43 arcseconds/century more than Newton predicts (commonly taught reference value); GR accounts for it exactly.
  • Starlight grazing the Sun bends ~1.75 arcseconds — twice the Newtonian estimate; measured by Eddington in 1919 during a total solar eclipse.
  • Gravitational redshift = light loses energy climbing out of a gravity well; confirmed by Pound–Rebka (1960) and used daily in GPS.
  • Gravity Probe B measured the geodetic effect and frame dragging, confirming that rotating Earth drags spacetime.
  • The Hulse–Taylor binary pulsar loses orbital energy at exactly the rate GR predicts for gravitational-wave emission (Nobel 1993).
  • GW150914 (2015) = first direct gravitational-wave detection; the signal matched GR's predicted waveform.
  • A single test is suggestive; the theory's strength comes from many independent tests agreeing.

Check yourself

5 review questions from the chapter. Try each one, then open the answer.

  1. What are the three classic tests of general relativity, and what did each one measure?

    Show answer

    (1) Mercury's perihelion precession — the orbit's closest-approach point advances ~43 arcseconds/century more than Newton predicts; (2) deflection of starlight — light passing near the Sun bends ~1.75 arcseconds; (3) gravitational redshift — light climbing out of a gravity well shifts toward longer (redder) wavelengths.

  2. Why was Mercury's orbit a problem for Newtonian gravity, and how did GR solve it?

    Show answer

    The measured precession of Mercury's orbit exceeded the Newtonian prediction by ~43 arcseconds per century. GR predicted exactly this extra amount because spacetime curvature near the Sun alters Mercury's path.

  3. Why does starlight bend near the Sun if light has no mass?

    Show answer

    Light has no mass, but it follows the straightest possible path through curved spacetime (a geodesic). Near the Sun, spacetime is curved, so that path curves with it.

  4. How did the Hulse–Taylor binary pulsar provide evidence for gravitational waves before LIGO existed?

    Show answer

    The pulsar's orbit shrinks by ~76 microseconds per year — exactly the energy loss predicted if the system radiates gravitational waves. The measured rate matched GR's prediction decades before LIGO.

  5. Name the two effects Gravity Probe B was designed to measure, and which one is much larger.

    Show answer

    The geodetic effect (~6.6 arcseconds/year, from orbiting through curved spacetime) and frame dragging (~0.039 arcseconds/year, from Earth's rotation dragging spacetime). The geodetic effect is far larger.

Keep learning

Ready to build on this? Continue to the next lesson.

Study tools & related lessonsKey vocabulary · Related

Key vocabulary

General relativity (GR)
Einstein's theory that gravity is the curvature of spacetime caused by mass and energy
Perihelion precession
The slow rotation of an orbit's closest-approach point
Arcsecond
1/3600 of a degree; a tiny angle used for celestial measurements
Geodesic
The straightest possible path between two points in curved spacetime
Gravitational redshift
The stretching (reddening) of light as it climbs out of a gravity well
Frame dragging
A rotating mass drags nearby spacetime around with it
Geodetic effect
The precession of a gyroscope caused by orbiting through curved spacetime
Gravitational wave
A ripple in spacetime itself, traveling at the speed of light

Sources & references

  1. openstax.org — Astronomy 2e

This lesson was adapted from the open educational references above; their licenses and attributions are preserved. See Copyright & Licensing.

Educational content only. It is not medical, legal or professional advice. Found an error? Tell us.