Fundamentals of Nursing · Legal and Ethical Considerations

Value Considerations of Care

9 min read

On this page 9 sections

In 30 seconds
Why this matters
The college version
Eli explains
Worked example
Key takeaway
Check yourself
Study tools
Sources & references

In 30 seconds

A is a deeply held belief about what is important, desirable, or worthwhile — a conviction that guides choices. Everyone carries a personal value system: the collection of beliefs (about family, health, religion, work, autonomy, and more) built over a lifetime. Health care is full of value-loaded decisions — starting or stopping treatment, accepting a blood transfusion, how much information a person wants, who should be in the room, what "quality of life" means. Value considerations of care is the study of how those beliefs shape health decisions — and how nurses care for people whose values differ from their own.

This topic opens Chapter 16 because values underlie everything else in it: ethics (Topic 2) asks what ought to be done when values conflict, law (Topic 3) sets the enforceable floor, and advocacy (Topic 4) is what the nurse does with the answers. First, though, the nurse must understand the raw material — what the patient values, and what the nurse values.

Why this matters

Patients rarely decide from facts alone — they decide from values applied to facts. A person may understand that a recommended treatment works and still refuse it, because it conflicts with something they hold more important: religious beliefs, family obligations, fear of dependency, or a different definition of a life worth living. A nurse who cannot recognize this will misread refusal as confusion, stubbornness, or ignorance — and push in ways that damage trust.

Values matter for the nurse, too. Every nurse brings into the room; when those collide with a patient's choices, the nurse can feel judgment, discomfort, or distress. Professional nursing requires awareness of your own values — built through — so you can care for people without imposing your value system on them. It is a tested skill and a daily duty.

The college version

Core Concepts

What values are and how they form

Values are learned, not born. They develop through family upbringing, culture and community, religion and spirituality, education, peers, media, and life experience — including experiences of illness and health care itself. Values are stable but not fixed; serious illness, caregiving, or a move to a new country can reorganize priorities. A person's values show in choices, words, and behavior — and sometimes in what they don't say.

Personal values versus professional values

Personal values belong to the individual: "my family comes first," "I believe life should be preserved at all costs."
are the commitments of the profession — for nursing: respect for human dignity, the primacy of the patient's interests, compassion, integrity, accountability, and social justice — codified in documents like the ANA Code of Ethics for Nurses (U.S.) and equivalent codes internationally (Topic 2).

The two can conflict: a nurse's personal beliefs may oppose a patient's lawful choice. Professional values require separating the two — personal judgment does not license withholding respectful care.

Values clarification

Values clarification is the process of examining and naming your own values: identifying what you believe, where it came from, how strongly you hold it, and whether your behavior matches it. Exercises like rank-ordering what matters most and discussing "what would you do" cases build this awareness. The purpose is not to tell people what to value or to change anyone's values — it is to make values visible so they can be examined honestly. For nurses, clarifying their own values is a prerequisite for not imposing them.

How values shape health decisions

Values influence nearly every clinical choice: whether to accept, continue, or stop treatments, and tolerance of risk; end-of-life decisions such as advance directives and resuscitation preferences (legally detailed in Topic 3); refusals of specific therapies on religious or cultural grounds (e.g., blood products) and preferences for traditional approaches; information and decision-making style — some people want every detail and full control, others prefer family or clinician to decide, and both can be valid; and everyday care — modesty and privacy, caregiver gender, diet, prayer, and who may be present.

The nurse's job is to assess these preferences (asking respectfully, with professional interpretation when language differs), document them, and build the plan of care around them — not judge them against the nurse's own scale.

When patient values and nurse values conflict

Conflicts are normal and not automatically a problem. The professional response: (1) recognize the conflict and name the specific value at stake on each side; (2) separate facts from values — the clinical facts may be undisputed while the choice differs, because values differ; (3) remember the patient's right to self-determination (autonomy, Topic 2) within legal and safety limits — respecting a lawful, informed refusal is not "losing"; (4) if the nurse's personal values make a situation unbearable, discuss it with a supervisor, request a different assignment per policy, and — where law and employer policy allow — use to specific acts (never blanket refusal, never abandonment); (5) seek support — unresolved value conflicts contribute to (the anguish of knowing the right thing and being blocked from doing it), a real occupational hazard addressed in Topic 2.

Asking without assuming

Values are personal even when they come from a shared culture. Two people from the same religious or cultural community can hold very different values. The respectful habit is to ask ("How would you like decisions about your care handled? What matters most to you right now?") rather than assume from a name, language, or appearance. Values assessment is part of the admission and ongoing nursing assessment — not a box to tick once.

Common Confusions

Do Not Confuse	With	Difference
A patient's values	The nurse's values	The patient's choices should reflect the patient's value system; imposing your own is the error exams test
Values	Facts	A fact is what is true; a value is what matters. Patients can fully understand the facts and still choose differently
Values	Ethics / morals	Values are beliefs; morals are personal codes; ethics is the systematic study of what ought to be done. Values feed into all three
Values clarification	Teaching values	Clarification names and examines values; it never tells anyone what to believe
Cultural values	Stereotypes	Culture informs values; it does not dictate them. Ask the individual, don't assume from a group label

Eli explains

The same idea, in plain words

Explain it like I’m 10

Everyone carries an invisible list of "what matters most to me." Your list might say "never give up," while your neighbor's says "stay comfortable with my family nearby." When a person is sick, they make choices using their list — and the nurse's job is to understand the patient's list and help them follow it, even if the nurse's own list says something different.

Worked example

Mr. Delgado, a 68-year-old man with a newly diagnosed condition, is offered a treatment with a good chance of extending life but a demanding schedule of appointments and side effects that would keep him from his work as the primary caregiver for his wife, who has advanced dementia. He declines. The nurse's first instinct is to explain the treatment again, more thoroughly — assuming he didn't understand. Then the nurse pauses and asks, "What matters most to you in this decision?" Mr. Delgado answers: "My wife needs me at home. If I can't be there for her, the extra time isn't worth it to me."

This is not a comprehension problem — it is a values problem: family duty outranks the treatment's benefits in his value system. The nurse does not argue or re-pitch the treatment. Instead, the nurse explores options that might honor both values (e.g., support services that could let him take the treatment and care for his wife), reports his reasoning to the provider and care team, documents his expressed preferences, and involves social work for caregiver support — building care around his values rather than against them.

Key takeaways

Values = deeply held beliefs that guide choices; learned from family, culture, religion, education, and experience — and they shape nearly every health decision.
Personal values ≠ professional values: professional nursing values (dignity, patient's interests first, integrity, social justice) bind the nurse even when personal beliefs differ.
Values clarification names and examines values — it never changes the patient's values or preaches your own.
Assess values by asking, not assuming — culture informs values but does not dictate them.
A lawful, informed refusal based on the patient's values is the patient's right, not a failure of the nurse — respect and document it; when your own values conflict with a patient's choices, keep care respectful, escalate per policy, and use support resources.
Conscientious objection (where allowed) targets a specific act and never abandons the patient; blanket refusal of a person is discrimination.

Check yourself

5 review questions from the chapter. Try each one, then open the answer.

A patient declines a treatment you believe is clearly beneficial. Before re-explaining the treatment, what should you do, and why?
Show answer
Ask what matters most to the patient in this decision (e.g., "What are your main concerns?"). Refusal is often a values-based choice, not a comprehension failure — understanding the patient's values first prevents treating a legitimate preference as a misunderstanding.
What is values clarification, and what is it not for?
Show answer
Values clarification is the process of identifying, examining, and ranking your own values — where they came from, how strongly you hold them, whether your behavior matches. It is not for changing anyone's values or telling patients what they should value.
Give an example of how personal and professional values can conflict, and what the professional response is.
Show answer
Example: a nurse personally believes all blood products should be accepted, but a patient lawfully refuses them on religious grounds. The professional response: keep personal belief separate from professional duty — provide respectful care, honor the lawful refusal, document, and involve the team/ethics resources as needed.
A colleague says, "Patients from that community always refuse this." What is the respectful, accurate response?
Show answer
That assumption is a stereotype: culture informs values but does not dictate them, and individuals within any community vary. Ask each patient directly about their preferences and document them.
What is moral distress, and what should a nurse do when it develops?
Show answer
Moral distress is the anguish of knowing the right thing and being unable to do it. The nurse should not carry it silently: discuss with supervisors/preceptors, use debriefing, and access employee support or ethics resources per institutional policy.

Keep learning

Ready to build on this? Continue to the next lesson.

Study tools & related lessonsKey vocabulary · Related

Key vocabulary

Value: A deeply held belief about what is important or worthwhile
Personal values: The beliefs an individual holds from life experience
Professional values: The commitments of the profession (dignity, patient's interests, integrity)
Values clarification: Naming, examining, and honestly assessing your own values
Moral distress: Anguish from knowing the right thing and being blocked from doing it
Conscientious objection: Declining to participate in a specific act on moral grounds

Sources & references

openstax.org — Fundamentals Nursing

This lesson was adapted from the open educational references above; their licenses and attributions are preserved. See Copyright & Licensing.

Educational content only. It is not medical, legal or professional advice. Found an error? Tell us.